Explore like a local with custom itineraries

What can we help you discover?

Apple cider slush topped with maple creemee and a cider donut at Cold Hollow Cider Mill in Waterbury Center

Vermont Fall

Try the Apple Cider Crushee at Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Jump to In this guide

Apple cider. Maple creemee. Cider donut.

There are plenty of ways to taste fall in Vermont, but Cold Hollow Cider Mill  decided there was no reason you should have to choose just one.

The Apple Cider Crushee combines all three into one gloriously over-the-top Vermont fall treat: an apple cider slushie topped with maple creemee and finished with one of Cold Hollow’s famous cider donuts. It’s cold, creamy, tangy, sweet and a little ridiculous in exactly the way a fall road-trip treat should be.

You’ll find it at Cold Hollow Cider Mill along Route 100 in Waterbury Center, between Waterbury and Stowe. Cold Hollow has been here since 1974, and while you can visit year-round for fresh cider, cider donuts, maple products and other Vermont-made foods, fall is when this place really comes alive.

And yes, it gets busy. But I’d still stop.

Apple cider slushie topped with a maple creemee and cider donut in Vermont

Meet Cold Hollow Cider Mill in Waterbury Center

Cold Hollow Cider Mill was founded in 1974 and operates from a 19th-century farmhouse and historic dairy barn along Route 100. Today, the property includes the working cider mill, bakery, retail market and café, making this much more than a quick stop for a gallon of cider.

You can watch cider being made, browse Vermont products, grab breakfast or lunch and, most importantly for me, eat something involving cider donuts.

Cold Hollow is located at 3600 Waterbury-Stowe Road in Waterbury Center, putting it directly on one of the busiest fall travel corridors in Vermont. It’s a natural stop if you’re driving between Waterbury and Stowe, and it’s also close enough to several other Waterbury-area destinations that you can easily build it into a full day.

But if you only have time for one thing?

Get the Crushee.

What Is the Cold Hollow Apple Cider Crushee?

The Apple Cider Crushee essentially takes three classic Vermont flavors and stacks them into one dessert.

It starts with an apple cider slushie, which gives you that sweet-tart apple flavor but in an icy form that’s particularly refreshing if your fall visit happens to land on one of those unexpectedly warm October afternoons.

Next comes maple creemee.

Then Cold Hollow puts one of its cider donuts right on top.

It’s the kind of combination that sounds like it might be too much until you start eating it and realize each component does something different. The slushie is cold and tangy, the maple creemee makes everything richer and creamier, and the cider donut gives you the cake-like texture and warm spice you were probably going to order anyway.

You were going to get a cider donut, right? Exactly.

The red entrance and welcome sign at Cold Hollow Cider Mill in Waterbury Center

It Starts With Cold Hollow’s Fresh Apple Cider

The cider is what ties the whole thing together.

Cold Hollow has been pressing cider since the business was founded in 1974, using a traditional rack-and-cloth approach that crushes apples and presses the mash between layers of cloth. The mill says its cider is primarily made with McIntosh apples blended with varieties including Honeycrisp, Gala and Rome, creating the balance of sweetness, tartness and apple flavor that carries through whether you’re drinking the cider straight or turning it into a frozen treat.

The equipment itself is evolving. Cold Hollow announced in 2026 that it is transitioning from its old 1920s rack-and-cloth press to a newer GoodNature Maximizer that follows the same basic rack-and-cloth principle. The mill notes that it actually used an earlier version of a GoodNature press during the 1990s, so the change is more of an equipment update than a departure from the way Cold Hollow approaches cider making.

If cider is being pressed when you visit, take the time to watch.

It’s easy to think of apple cider as simply another fall drink until you actually see how much fruit and work goes into making it.

Rows of cider donuts on trays and a rack at Cold Hollow Cider Mill in Waterbury Center, Vermont

Then Comes the Maple Creemee

If you’re new to Vermont, you also need to know about creemees.

A creemee is Vermont’s version of soft serve, and maple is the flavor you’ll see everywhere from roadside stands to sugarhouses around the state. At Cold Hollow, that maple creemee becomes the creamy middle layer of the Crushee.

The combination of maple and apple is what makes this taste so distinctly like Vermont fall to me. Neither flavor needs to be reinvented or made complicated. You have tart-sweet cider on the bottom and maple on top, and they work.

Cold Hollow also serves maple creemees on their own, so you don’t have to commit to the full Crushee experience every time you visit. The mill specifically lists maple creemees among the classic experiences visitors can have on site.

But you’re already here.

I think you know which direction I’m going to steer you.

And Finally, Add a Cider Donut

The cider donut perched on top isn’t merely decoration.

Cold Hollow’s cider donuts are made fresh daily on the mill’s old-fashioned donut machines. They’re relatively small, about 2.5 inches across, with cider in the recipe and the lightly spiced cake-donut texture that has made them one of the mill’s signature foods.

They also happen to be conveniently sized for sticking on top of a creemee.

I highly recommend getting more than the one that comes with your Crushee. Buy a dozen to take with you, especially if you’re continuing north toward Stowe or heading out for a day of foliage driving.

Cold Hollow sells the donuts year-round rather than treating them solely as a fall food, although there’s something about eating one on a crisp October day that feels considerably more appropriate.

And if they’re warm? Eat one immediately.

Don’t Leave Without Exploring the Market

The Crushee may be the reason for this particular stop, but don’t grab it and immediately leave.

Cold Hollow carries a large assortment of Vermont-made products alongside its own cider, bakery items and maple foods. Current offerings include Vermont maple syrup, fudge, cider jelly, maple butter, granola, pancake mixes, apple pie and plenty of other things that can very quickly turn a snack stop into a shopping trip.

This is a good place to stock up if you’re visiting Vermont and want food gifts that people will actually use rather than another souvenir with a moose on it.

Grab cider. Get maple syrup. Buy the dozen donuts.

Then browse and see what else ends up following you to the register.

There’s Also a Café at Cold Hollow

If the Crushee isn’t substantial enough to qualify as lunch, and I suppose technically it isn’t, Cold Hollow also has an on-site café serving breakfast and lunch.

That makes the mill particularly convenient for a Route 100 road trip because you can accomplish several important Vermont tasks in one stop: eat something savory, watch cider being made, buy local products and then order a dessert containing apple cider, maple creemee and a donut.

Efficiency.

Current café service includes breakfast and lunch, but hours can change, so check the mill’s current schedule before planning a meal around your visit.

When to Visit Cold Hollow Cider Mill in Fall

Here’s the part people don’t always want to hear.

Cold Hollow gets busy in fall.

Really busy.

The mill sits directly on Route 100 between Waterbury and Stowe, one of the most heavily traveled stretches of road during peak foliage season. Cold Hollow itself is also one of Vermont’s most visited attractions, according to the mill.

My recommendation is to visit on a weekday if your schedule allows it. If you’re going on a weekend, get an early start rather than waiting for the middle of the day when everyone else traveling between Waterbury and Stowe has the same idea.

That applies to your entire fall trip, not just Cold Hollow.

Vermont is spectacular during peak foliage, but sitting in a long line of traffic isn’t the Vermont experience you’ve traveled here to have. Start earlier, slow down once you arrive and leave enough room in your itinerary that you’re not racing from one famous fall stop to another.

Frozen cocoa topped with whipped cream and a cider donut outside Cold Hollow Cider Mill in winter.

Make Cold Hollow Part of a Waterbury and Stowe Fall Day

Cold Hollow’s location makes it incredibly easy to add to a bigger fall itinerary.

If you’re starting in Waterbury, you can visit the mill before continuing north toward Stowe. Spend the rest of the day exploring the Stowe Recreation Path, driving Route 108 toward Smugglers’ Notch while the road remains seasonally open or heading toward one of the area’s hiking trails and foliage viewpoints.

You can also keep your day focused around Waterbury, where there are plenty of other food and drink stops worth exploring.

The important part is not trying to cram every recognizable Vermont attraction into the same afternoon.

Cold Hollow is more enjoyable when you give yourself enough time to watch the cider-making process, walk around the market and actually sit somewhere to finish your Crushee instead of immediately carrying it back to the car.

Is the Cold Hollow Crushee Worth Trying?

Yes. And I say that as someone who has eaten an unreasonable number of Vermont fall treats.

What I like about the Crushee is that it isn’t trying to invent a new fall flavor. Instead, it takes three things Vermont already does extremely well and puts them together.

Apple cider. Maple creemee. Cider donut.

You get tart apple, sweet maple, warm spice, cold slush and creamy soft serve in the same cup.

Is it subtle? Absolutely not. Is it exactly what I want during a Vermont fall road trip? Absolutely.

Visit Cold Hollow Cider Mill for current hours and visitor information before you go. Then get there early, order the Crushee and grab a dozen cider donuts for whatever adventure comes next.

Just don’t expect that dozen to make it home.

@travelikealocalvt

Make a day of it

Liked this? Here’s what’s nearby

  • Inn

    Old Stage Coach Inn

    Waterbury, VT

    A historic inn on Main Street in Waterbury, with breakfast, a cozy pub and a convenient base for Stowe and the Green Mountains.

  • Bar or pub

    Blackback Pub

    Waterbury, VT

    I can’t introduce you to Vermont food without introducing you to Vermont beer, and Waterbury is one of the best places to do both. 13 Places…

Talk with locals

Comments

Join the conversation

Be the first to chime in

Been here? Your tip could save the next visitor a wrong turn.