Explore like a local with custom itineraries

What can we help you discover?

Vermont Creemee Season
Vermont Creemee Season

Creemees

The Best Creemees in Vermont: 10 Spots to Try

Jump to In this guide

The summer I turned pretty? Nah.

This was the summer I ate too many Vermont creemees, and I enjoyed every single one.

There are certain foods that just taste like Vermont summer, and a maple creemee might be at the very top of that list. It’s the post-hike reward, the reason to pull over when you see a handwritten sign on the side of the road and the treat I’ll happily drive well out of my way for.

And while maple is the classic, Vermont’s creemee scene has gotten considerably more interesting. You’ll find maple made with syrup produced right at the sugarhouse, maple-black raspberry twists, homemade waffle cones, maple dust, rotating seasonal flavors and some completely unexpected options. Pickle creemee, anyone?

I’ve eaten my way through a lot of them.

So if you’re looking for the best creemees in Vermont, these are 10 of my favorite stops, from the Champlain Islands to Southern Vermont.

What Is a Vermont Creemee?

First things first: if you’re visiting Vermont and wondering why everyone keeps talking about creemees, you’re essentially looking at Vermont’s version of soft-serve ice cream.

But calling a Vermont maple creemee “soft serve” feels like you’re missing the point.

The classic flavor is maple, ideally made with real Vermont maple syrup and served in a cone with that dense, smooth, creamy texture that makes you understand why Vermonters have given the treat its own name.

You’ll see “creemee” spelled a few different ways around the state, and you’ll find plenty of debate about exactly what qualifies as one. I’m less interested in policing the spelling than I am in finding the really good ones.

These are the places I keep going back to.

1. Palmer Lane Maple in Jericho

If someone asked me where to start their Vermont creemee education, Palmer Lane Maple would be high on my list.

This Jericho favorite started serving creemees in 2013 after customers kept asking the owners to add them to their maple business. What began with one maple flavor has grown into a destination with multiple machines, rotating flavors, toppings and even creemee trucks.

The maple is the classic order here, and don’t skip the maple sprinkles. They’re made from crunchy pieces of maple candy and add just enough texture and extra maple flavor to the cone.

You’ll also find rotating creemee flavors throughout the season, so even if you’ve been before, there’s usually a reason to see what’s on the board.

My pick: Maple with maple sprinkles, unless one of the rotating flavors convinces me otherwise.

2. Devyn’s Creemee Stand in Swanton

If Palmer Lane is where I’d send someone for a classic Vermont maple experience, Devyn’s is where I’d send the more adventurous creemee eater.

This small-town Swanton creemee stand isn’t afraid to get weird with its flavors, and I mean that as a compliment.

Pickle creemee is probably the one that’s going to get your attention first.

Yes, pickle.

But that’s part of what makes Devyn’s fun. The rotating flavors can venture well beyond the standard chocolate, vanilla and maple lineup, so check what’s being served when you visit and try something you wouldn’t normally order.

You can get maple creemees all over Vermont. You cannot say the same about pickle.

My pick: Whatever flavor sounds like it absolutely shouldn’t work.

3. Red Hen Baking  in Montpelier

You probably know Red Hen for bread and pastries. Go for the creemee, too.

Red Hen Baking started in Duxbury in 1999 and now operates its café in downtown Montpelier. Along with its artisan breads, pastries, sandwiches and coffee, the bakery serves creemees with maple plus a rotating specialty flavor.

And because this is a bakery, pay attention to the cone.

A great creemee is even better when the cone isn’t an afterthought, and Red Hen’s homemade cones are a big part of why this one makes my list.

The rotating flavor is also worth checking before automatically ordering maple. Recent combinations have included maple with fresh ginger, which is exactly the kind of slightly unexpected flavor pairing Red Hen does well.

My pick: Get the maple twisted with whatever seasonal flavor they’re serving, in the homemade cone.

4. Little Gordo Creemee Stand in Burlington

Little Gordo is for the person who wants to see what happens when you give the humble Vermont creemee a little more personality.

The creemees here are exceptionally creamy, but it’s the flavor combinations that keep me interested. Instead of simply choosing between maple and vanilla, you can find creative rotating flavors and combinations that make each visit a little different.

This is a good stop to work into a Burlington day when you want dessert without leaving town for a traditional roadside creemee stand.

Come hungry enough to try something beyond your usual order.

My pick: Check the current flavors and get a twist. This isn’t where I’d play it safe.

5. Judi’s  in Williston

Judi’s is another place where the creemee is only the beginning.

You can absolutely order a classic cone, but the Twistees are where things get particularly fun. These take a creemee and mix it with different candies, cereals and other additions for something closer to a fully loaded dessert.

My weakness? The Cinnamon Toast Crunch.

It’s nostalgic, crunchy, creamy and considerably more elaborate than the maple cone you might pick up at a sugarhouse. That’s exactly why I think both deserve space on a Vermont creemee list.

Some days call for pure maple. Some call for cereal mixed into your ice cream.

My pick: The Cinnamon Toast Crunch Twistee.

6. Silloway Maple  in Randolph Center

For the other end of the Vermont creemee spectrum, head to a working sugarhouse.

Silloway Maple in Randolph Center has been producing maple for generations, evolving from gathering sap with horses and buckets in the 1940s to the modern sugaring equipment used today.

This is maple right from the source.

Come for a maple creemee, browse the maple products and take some time to appreciate the fact that the ingredient responsible for the flavor in your cone comes from the same Vermont landscape surrounding you.

If you’re interested in maple beyond the creemee, this is also a particularly fun stop during sugaring season, when Silloway hosts tours and maple events.

My pick: Maple in a cone. Don’t overcomplicate this one.

7. Lu Lu  in Vergennes

Lu Lu proves that you don’t have to be a sugarhouse to earn a spot on a Vermont creemee road trip. This Vergennes ice cream shop is known for its homemade ice cream, and the rotating creemee flavors can be just as interesting.

I’ve seen flavors here venture into combinations you don’t encounter at traditional stands, and Lu Lu is also one of my favorite stops if you’re traveling with someone who would rather have hard ice cream than a creemee.

And yes, I care about the sprinkles. Lu Lu has some of the prettiest.

Stop here while you’re exploring downtown Vergennes, grab a cone and walk around Vermont’s smallest city.

My pick: Whatever specialty creemee is on rotation, with sprinkles.

8. Vermont Maple Outlet  in Jeffersonville

If your Vermont creemee philosophy is that maple producers should know how to make a maple creemee, the Vermont Maple Outlet belongs on your list.

This family-run Jeffersonville business has been producing Vermont maple syrup for more than 100 years, and its country store is essentially a maple lover’s playground. You’ll find syrup, maple cream, maple candy and plenty of other Vermont products, plus an on-site sugarhouse where you can learn more about how maple syrup is made.

And, of course, you’re here for the creemee.

I love stops like this because the experience goes beyond simply ordering dessert. You can stock up on maple products, see the sugarhouse and then eat the ingredient you’ve been learning about in creemee form.

My pick: Maple. Obviously.

9. The Village Scoop in Colchester

This one is my neighborhood creemee stop, which means I’ve had plenty of opportunities to determine my order.

The Village Scoop is an easy drive-through option in Colchester with the kind of big waffle cones that immediately make a creemee feel like a proper summer event.

And while maple on its own is always good, this is where I’m going to advocate for another Vermont creemee classic:

Maple-black raspberry twist. The tart berry flavor against sweet maple just works, particularly in a big waffle cone. If you’ve been ordering straight maple everywhere you go, this is your sign to branch out.

My pick: Maple-black raspberry twist in a waffle cone.

10. Green Mountain Sugar House  in Ludlow

Heading to Southern Vermont? Save room for a creemee at Green Mountain Sugar House.

This family-run sugarhouse has been producing Vermont maple products since 1955 and has turned its maple creemee into a destination of its own. The creemee is made with pure Vermont maple syrup, and you can add maple-dusted cones, maple crunchies or turn the whole thing into a sundae or milkshake.

Even better for people who refuse to accept that creemees are strictly a summer food: Green Mountain Sugar House serves them year-round.

I especially like pairing this stop with a Southern Vermont adventure. Hike to Buttermilk Falls, explore the Ludlow area and reward yourself afterward with a maple creemee.

That’s a pretty solid Vermont day.

My pick: Maple in a maple-dusted cone.

Sugarhouse Creemee or Creative Creemee?

After eating a completely reasonable number of creemees around Vermont in the name of research, I’ve decided you really need to experience both.

Start with the classic.

Go somewhere like Silloway Maple, Vermont Maple Outlet or Green Mountain Sugar House where maple is the entire point. Order the maple creemee and taste what happens when one of Vermont’s signature agricultural products becomes its signature summer dessert.

Then branch out.

Try the maple-black raspberry twist at The Village Scoop. See what’s rotating at Palmer Lane or Red Hen. Order a loaded Twistee at Judi’s. Let Little Gordo surprise you.

And if you’re feeling particularly brave, go find the pickle creemee at Devyn’s.

There’s room for all of it.

When Is Creemee Season in Vermont?

Summer is prime creemee season, but the answer increasingly depends on where you go.

Many roadside stands and seasonal shops operate primarily during the warmer months, while some Vermont creemee destinations have expanded their seasons considerably. Green Mountain Sugar House in Ludlow, for example, serves maple creemees year-round. Red Hen’s current Montpelier café hours also include creemee service throughout the week.

For smaller seasonal stands, always check current hours before making a long drive specifically for a cone. Flavor availability changes frequently, too, which is half the fun.

Build Your Own Vermont Creemee Road Trip

I don’t recommend attempting all 10 of these in one day.

Actually, I very strongly recommend against it.

Instead, make creemees part of the Vermont exploring you’re already doing.

If you’re around Burlington and northern Vermont, work in The Village Scoop, Palmer Lane, Devyn’s or Little Gordo. Heading through Central Vermont? Try Red Hen, Silloway Maple or one of the many creemee stops around the Mad River Valley. In Southern Vermont, make Green Mountain Sugar House part of a Route 100 drive.

That’s really my favorite way to do it.

Don’t race around Vermont checking creemees off a list. Go for the hike, explore the town, swim in the river, stop at the farmstand and take the back road.

Then find a creemee.

So, Who Makes the Best Creemee in Vermont?

I’m not picking just one.

Part of the fun of Vermont creemee culture is that the answer depends on what you’re looking for.

Maybe it’s maple syrup made right at the sugarhouse. Maybe it’s an exceptionally creamy maple-black raspberry twist. Maybe it’s a homemade cone, an unexpected rotating flavor or enough Cinnamon Toast Crunch mixed into your creemee to qualify as a second meal.

For me, summer in Vermont means sticky fingers, supporting local businesses and deciding that one more maple creemee is probably reasonable.

The summer I turned pretty?

I’ll take the summer I ate my way through Vermont’s creemee stands instead.

@travelikealocalvt

The places in this guide, on the map

  1. Red Hen Baking

    Bakery · Montpelier, VT

    The perfect spot for a loaf of bread, sandwich, creemee or coffee. Don't miss the honor-stand bread room!

    Directions to Red Hen Baking (opens in a new tab)
  2. Judi’s Ice Cream – Williston

    Creemee or ice cream stand · Taft Corners, VT

    Try a Twistee, which mixes a creemee with candies, cereals, and other additions for a fully loaded dessert.

    Directions to Judi’s Ice Cream – Williston (opens in a new tab)
  3. Silloway Maple

    Creemee or ice cream stand · Randolph, VT

    I come here when I want a maple creemee with strong sweetness and an especially creamy consistency.

    Directions to Silloway Maple (opens in a new tab)
  4. Lu Lu

    Creemee or ice cream stand · Vergennes, VT

    If the limoncello creemee is available, get it. Sample the unique ice cream flavors and be wowed!

    Directions to Lu Lu (opens in a new tab)
  5. Vermont Maple Outlet

    Creemee or ice cream stand · Cambridge, VT

    Go for the maple creemee if you like a seriously dense maple flavor.

    Directions to Vermont Maple Outlet (opens in a new tab)
  6. Green Mountain Sugar House

    Creemee or ice cream stand · Ludlow, VT

    Save room for a maple creemee - one of the purist mape flavored creemees you'll find! Hike Butternut Falls afterwards.

    Directions to Green Mountain Sugar House (opens in a new tab)

Talk with locals

Comments

Join the conversation

Quick check: tick the box to send.

Be the first to chime in

Been here? Your tip could save the next visitor a wrong turn.