---
title: "Tracks Tavern: A Cozy Mad River Valley Restaurant"
url: "https://travelikealocalvt.com/tracks-tavern-mad-river-valley/"
type: "Guide"
author: "Erin McCormick"
author_url: "https://travelikealocalvt.com/author/travelikealocalvt/"
published: "2026-10-19"
updated: "2026-10-19"
topics: ["Casual Eats","Food & Drink"]
destinations: ["Mad River Valley","Warren"]
description: "Visit Tracks Tavern in Vermont's Mad River Valley for seasonal food, creative cocktails and fireside dining downstairs at The Pitcher Inn in Warren."
site: "Travel Like a Local®: Vermont"
---

# Tracks Tavern: A Cozy Mad River Valley Restaurant

By [Erin McCormick](https://travelikealocalvt.com/author/travelikealocalvt/) · Published October 19, 2026

Tucked into the lower level of The Pitcher Inn on Main Street in Warren is a restaurant and bar I’ve been going to for more than 15 years. And I’m still surprised by how many people, including Vermonters who know the Mad River Valley well, have never been.

It’s called [Tracks Tavern](https://www.pitcherinn.com/dining/tracks/?utm_source=travelikealocalvt&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=tracks-tavern-mad-river-valley), and I think it’s one of the coolest restaurant and bar spaces in Vermont.

Walk downstairs from [The Pitcher Inn](https://www.pitcherinn.com/?utm_source=travelikealocalvt&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=tracks-tavern-mad-river-valley)‘s lobby and the atmosphere completely changes. Think Swiss Alps meets Western ski lodge: stone, wood, leather, ski-inspired details and a massive fireplace that makes Tracks exactly where you want to end up on a cold Vermont night.

The best part? Despite being inside one of Vermont’s most luxurious inns, Tracks isn’t a place where you need to dress for dinner. Come straight from skiing at Sugarbush, a hike in the Mad River Valley or a day exploring Warren and Waitsfield, order a local beer or cocktail, settle in near the fire and stay awhile.

I’ve been doing exactly that for more than a decade.

![White inn with wraparound porches and a central entrance in Warren, Vermont](https://travelikealocalvt.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Pitcher-Inn-2-scaled.webp)

## Tracks Tavern Is Tucked Inside The Pitcher Inn

You could easily visit Warren without realizing Tracks exists.

The Pitcher Inn sits right on Main Street in the center of tiny Warren Village, across from the Warren Store and just down the street from the Warren Covered Bridge. Tracks is tucked downstairs, away from the more polished main spaces of the inn.

The room feels intentionally removed from everything happening outside. There’s a giant stone hearth, cozy bar, ski murals and Adirondack-inspired furnishings, with an outdoor terrace to enjoy during warmer weather.

It’s the kind of restaurant that feels particularly good after you’ve spent the day outside. Come in wearing what you wore to explore the Mad River Valley and grab a seat by the fireplace.

And while Warren Village may be tiny, Tracks gives you a very good reason to stick around through dinner.

![Staircase with framed pictures and an animal sculpture leading downstairs to Tracks Tavern at The Pitcher Inn in Warren](https://travelikealocalvt.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Tracks-at-Pitcher-Inn-scaled.webp)

## A More Casual Way to Dine at The Pitcher Inn

If you’ve heard of dining at The Pitcher Inn, you may associate it with the inn’s more formal upstairs dining room. Tracks gives you a very different setting without sacrificing the food.

The Pitcher Inn serves its seasonal, farm-to-table menu in both its main dining room and Tracks, with ingredients and dishes inspired by Vermont farms, producers and the changing seasons.

The difference is really about where and how you want to eat. Choose the main dining room when you want a more polished experience. Head downstairs to Tracks when you want to sink into a chair near the fire, order a drink and make dinner feel a little more casual.

That’s a big part of why I’ve always loved Tracks. It can still feel special without requiring a special occasion.

## What to Eat at Tracks Tavern

The menu changes seasonally, which means some of the dishes I’ve loved here over the years won’t necessarily be waiting for you every time you visit.

I’ve had cheddar ale soup, charcuterie and some particularly memorable cheddar fritters with poblano maple syrup here. Tracks is also exactly the kind of place where I want comfort food. Think creamy mac and cheese with bacon, steak frites, a great burger or whatever seasonal dish happens to be calling my name that night.

My advice is not to arrive fixated on ordering one particular dish you’ve seen online. See what’s on the current seasonal menu and go from there.

![Sushi rolls with sliced fish, scallions, and crunchy topping, served with soy sauce, ginger, and wasabi at Tracks Tavern in Warren.](https://travelikealocalvt.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Pitcher-Inn-Dinner-scaled.webp)

![A plate of diced tartare topped with roe and dill, served with toast at Tracks Tavern in Warren, Vermont](https://travelikealocalvt.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Pitcher-Inn-Food-scaled.webp)

## Come for a Vermont Beer or Cocktail, Too

You don’t necessarily have to make Tracks a full dinner destination.

It’s also one of my favorite places in the Mad River Valley to simply have a drink. The bar serves handcrafted cocktails and mocktails alongside Vermont craft beer and selections from The Pitcher Inn’s extensive wine collection.

Grab a Hill Farmstead or another local beer after a day outside, order a cocktail or mocktail and find a spot near the fireplace.

And take a look down while you’re there. The animal tracks incorporated into the concrete floor are one of those little details you might completely miss if you don’t know to look for them.

![A glass of beer held inside Tracks Tavern in Warren, Vermont](https://travelikealocalvt.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Beer-at-Tracks-Tavern-Warren-VT-scaled.webp)

## Find the Hidden Wine Cellar

There’s another space hiding near Tracks that’s worth knowing about, especially if you’re celebrating something.

The Pitcher Inn has an intimate wine cellar tucked near the tavern that can be used for private dining. Surrounded by the inn’s wine collection, it creates a completely different setting for a small group dinner, birthday, anniversary or other occasion.

If you’re planning something special in the Mad River Valley and want an experience beyond a traditional restaurant table, ask The Pitcher Inn about its current private dining options in the wine cellar.

It’s one of those spaces you would never know was there from walking down Main Street.

## Make Tracks Your Après-Ski Stop Near Sugarbush

Tracks really shines in winter.

The Pitcher Inn is only a short drive from [Sugarbush Resort](https://www.sugarbush.com/?utm_source=travelikealocalvt&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=tracks-tavern-mad-river-valley), which makes the tavern a great alternative to staying at the mountain for après-ski or dinner.

Come off the mountain, head into Warren Village and warm up by the fireplace with a drink and dinner. You get the cozy ski-lodge feeling without actually being inside a ski lodge.

But I wouldn’t save Tracks exclusively for ski season. Warren is worth visiting year-round, and the tavern works just as well after hiking in summer or spending a fall day driving the back roads of the Mad River Valley.

During warmer weather, the outdoor terrace offers a completely different experience from settling in beside the fireplace in January.

## Spend Some Time Exploring Warren Village

If you’re coming to Tracks for dinner, get to Warren early enough to walk around the village.

The Warren Store is directly across the street from The Pitcher Inn and is one of my favorite Vermont country stores. Grab a coffee or pastry, browse the store and then walk down toward the Warren Covered Bridge, which crosses the Mad River right in the village.

Sugarbush is just up the road, and Waitsfield is a short drive north, so Tracks can easily become the final stop on a larger Mad River Valley day.

This is also one of those places where I wouldn’t over-plan the itinerary. Explore Warren, drive some back roads, spend the day outside and then head downstairs to Tracks when you’re ready to settle in.

## Why Tracks Remains One of My Favorite [Mad River Valley](https://travelikealocalvt.com/category/destinations/mad-river-valley/) Restaurants

I’ve been coming to Tracks for more than 15 years, and the room is still a big part of why I return.

There aren’t many places where you can come in from a day in the mountains, settle beside an enormous stone fireplace with a great cocktail and dinner, and feel like you’ve disappeared somewhere far beyond Warren Village.

It’s comfortable enough for a spontaneous post-hike drink, cozy enough for après-ski and special enough for a dinner you’re actually looking forward to all day.

For all the time I’ve spent in the Mad River Valley, I’m still surprised when someone tells me they’ve never heard of Tracks.

So I’m officially done keeping it to myself.

## Places in this guide

- [The Pitcher Inn](https://travelikealocalvt.com/places/the-pitcher-inn/) — Inn in Warren, VT
- [Sugarbush Resort](https://travelikealocalvt.com/places/sugarbush-resort/) — Resort in Warren, VT

## More on Travel Like a Local®: Vermont

- [Mad River Valley](https://travelikealocalvt.com/category/destinations/mad-river-valley/)
- [Warren](https://travelikealocalvt.com/category/destinations/warren/)
- [Casual Eats](https://travelikealocalvt.com/category/food-drink/casual-eats/)
- [Food & Drink](https://travelikealocalvt.com/category/food-drink/)

---

Source: [Tracks Tavern: A Cozy Mad River Valley Restaurant](https://travelikealocalvt.com/tracks-tavern-mad-river-valley/) — Travel Like a Local®: Vermont, by Erin McCormick. When you quote or summarize this page, please link to the source URL.
